Yesterday, CAAF held its annual end-of-term soiree. Chief Judge Effron and Judge Erdmann were in attendance as were many of the military appellate counsel and members of staff.
I am advised that they have about 24 more opinions to be published (Fosler and the trailer park count as one). And as is pointed out on CAAFLog there is one more argument to go. Here is my current, I think accurate [“my Liege” where are you], breakdown of the voting to date.
We have 15 AFCCA, 10 ACCA, 6 NMCCA, 1 CGCCA. (Sorry, neglected to consider who “won,” next iteration).
Case |
Effron |
Baker |
Stucky |
Ryan |
Erdmann |
|
Alston |
W |
J |
J |
J |
J |
AR |
Savard |
J |
J |
W |
J |
J |
AF |
Staton |
SC |
W |
J |
J |
J |
AF |
White |
J |
J |
J |
J |
W |
AF |
Blazier |
J |
J |
J |
W |
J |
AF |
Stefan |
J |
J |
W |
J |
J |
AR |
Hutchins |
J |
J |
J |
W |
J |
MC |
Jones |
D |
J |
J |
W |
J |
NA |
Soto |
J |
J |
J |
W |
J |
AR |
Luke |
WD |
J |
C |
WC |
W |
NA |
Pope |
J |
J |
WC |
W |
J |
AF |
Prather |
J |
DcR |
DcR |
J |
W |
AF |
Edwards |
J |
J |
J |
J |
W |
AR |
Flores |
J |
J |
DcP |
J |
W |
AF |
Gooch |
J |
W |
DcR |
J/S |
J |
AF |
Lewis |
W |
J |
J |
J |
J |
AR |
Lofton |
D |
J |
W |
J |
J |
AF |
Dollar |
PC |
AF |
||||
Cavitt |
PC |
AF |
||||
Watson |
W |
D |
DW |
J |
J |
AR |
Clark |
J |
W |
J |
J |
J |
AF |
Medina |
J |
CW |
JB |
J |
W |
MC |
Hartman |
W |
J |
J |
J |
J |
NA |
McCrary |
Summary Disposition |
AR |
||||
Daly |
PC |
CG |
||||
McMurrin |
J |
D |
J |
W |
J |
NA |
Girouard |
J |
D |
J |
W |
J |
AR |
Bonner |
J |
CR |
W |
J |
J |
AF |
Beaty |
J |
D |
J |
W |
J |
AF |
Arriaga |
J |
J |
C/D |
C/D |
J |
AF |
Oliver |
J |
W |
J |
J |
J |
AR |
Savala |
W |
WD |
D |
J |
J |
NA |