Close
Updated:

Confrontation on court records

Occasionally the prosecution wants to use court records,

There is an evidentiary exception that can apply.  But, what about the Confrontation Clause?  Federalevidence review has a post on that.

Eighth Circuit reverses conviction for being an accessory after the fact by assisting another (Clark) in avoiding apprehension for committing a murder based on Confrontation Clause violation resulting from the introduction of a Court Minute Entry (of “Clark’s guilty plea as conclusive proof that” he had committed the offense) and without an opportunity to cross-examine the declarants about the statements, in United States v. Head, _ F.3d _ (8th Cir. March 1, 2013) (No. 12-2625).

The Head decision underscores the risk in criminal cases in relying on court records which contain testimonial statements that are offered to prove the underlying matter asserted.

Contact Us
Start Chat